Mulla Sadra's Argument for the Eternity of Creation
Substantial Motion and the Nature of Creation
A fundamental aspect of Mulla Sadra’s philosophy is his effort to show how both the eternality of God’s creative act and the temporal emergence of the universe can coexist. In Al-Asfar al-Arba'a (The Four Journeys), Sadra develops an explanation using the concept of substantial motion, the character of time, and Allah’s eternally continuing creation.
Sadra starts by explaining the concept of substantial motion (al-haraka al-jawhariyya). Unlike philosophers who viewed motion mainly through changes in the characteristics of something, Sadra views material objects themselves as undergoing a continuous process of change. In Volume 4, page 84 of Al-Asfar, he explains that existence can possess continuity while being renewed at each instant.
This point is crucial to Sadra’s argument. Material existence is always in some degree of flux. Each state of a thing is newly produced; yet there exists a continuum of transformation in this thing. However, the fact that each individual state of existence has a beginning does not necessarily mean that the whole succession of states must have a first beginning.
Allah's Eternity and Immutability
Sadra’s interpretation is also consistent with his concepts regarding the eternality and immutability of Allah. He defines Allah’s knowledge and will as eternal and identical to His essence. Therefore, Allah does not need to gain a new intention in order to create, nor does Allah experience change.
Sadra thus establishes a clear separation between Allah’s continually ongoing creation and the continually changing existence of His creations. Creation may extend indefinitely into the past and future without any element within the physical universe having the same unchanging eternality as Allah.
My Response
I think this is a reasonable philosophical explanation for three reasons.
Firstly, I don’t believe that simply because a Creator has been eternal since all eternity means that creation itself had to start at a specific time. An eternal process of creating things can be conceived without assuming those things were independent of their Creator.
Secondly, Sadra’s theory of substantial motion offers a viable explanation for why creation can be continuously renewed without creating any change in Allah’s essence. Since change pertains to the realm of created existence and not to the essence of its Creator, Allah can maintain absolute immutability while creation is continuously transformed.
Thirdly, I consider the distinction between the eternity of creation as a process and the temporal origin of individual things very appealing. This model removes the assumption that an eternal succession necessitates that any single material object exists eternally.
A Possible Objection and Conclusion
However, Sadra's theory of substantial motion does not provide conclusive proof that the succession of creation has no first moment. One possible counterargument would be accepting continuous renewal while asserting that the process itself started.
Therefore, ultimately I think Mulla Sadra's argument has merit, because it demonstrates how an eternal succession of creation can occur concurrently with the complete dependence, temporal origin, and continued transformation of the material world.