The Metaphysics of The Healing
A review on Avicenna's "Al-Ilahiyyat Al Shifa' (my favorite read)"
Introduction
Among all the philosophical writings I've read, very few, if any, have had such a profound influence on my grasp of metaphysics as Avicenna’s Al-Ilāhiyyāt min Kitāb al-Shifāʾ (Metaphysics of the Healing). I find the unique contribution of this writing to be not just the conclusion Avicenna comes to, but the process of reasoning through which he arrives at his conclusions. Avicenna develops a metaphysical system that addresses existence, causality, and necessity to arrive at God through interconnected arguments.
While there are several philosophical writings that start with the assumption of the existence of God and proceed to describe God's attributes, Avicenna starts by addressing what it is to "be" and how existence is divided. Avicenna proceeds from that starting point to argue for the Necessary Existent, and ultimately the nature of the causal action of God.
Although I do not find each and every argument presented in this work equally persuasive, I see this work as one of the most intellectually stimulating contributions to metaphysics. Specifically, his discussions of necessity and contingency, divine simplicity, and the eternity of creation have shaped my philosophical viewpoint.
Books I–IV: Being, Essence, and Cause
Books I–IV represent the foundation of Avicenna's metaphysical system. One of the most important distinctions made here is that between essence and existence.
Existence deals with whether a thing actually exists; essence deals with what a thing is. To illustrate, we can know what constitutes a horse without knowing if a particular horse actually exists. A horse's essence does not provide information regarding its existence.
This distinction becomes crucial when Avicenna discusses, in Book I, Chapter 6, what is necessary through itself and what is possible through itself. A contingent being does not inherently have within its essence a sufficient reason for its existence. Therefore, its existence requires a cause. On the other hand, the Necessary Existent exists through itself and does not rely upon anything outside of itself.
What I appreciate about this distinction is that it explains why contingent existence needs an explanation. Avicenna does not merely inquire into the causal circumstances of a specific object's existence. He questions why contingent existence even requires an explanation.
In addition to explaining the cause-and-effect relationship between different things in Books III and IV, Avicenna uses causation to build upon his earlier account of divine creation. Notably, Avicenna posits that a complete cause necessitates an effect. This concept will be central to his eventual account of divine creation.
Book VIII: The Necessary Existent and Divine Simplicity
Some of the philosophical discussions contained in Book VIII I find most compelling. Of special interest to me are Avicenna's discussions of the Necessary Existent and divine attributes.
Avicenna asserts that the Necessary Existent cannot include compositional elements similar to those found in contingent beings. Were God composed of separate elements, God's existence would similarly be determined by those elements, thus contradicting His necessity through Himself.
Through his assertion that God is simple, Avicenna is attempting to establish the strongest possible notion of divine independence. Since God is necessary through Himself, it follows logically that God would need nothing else, including distinct metaphysical elements to function as He does.
However, divine simplicity creates its own set of problems. Since God's attributes are not seen as real entities independent of His essence, how can we distinguish between God's knowledge, power, and will? Although Avicenna develops an elaborate theory about these attributes, I think this area presents one of the greatest opportunities for further philosophical exploration.
Book IX: Divine Creation, Providence, and Evil
As far as discussions in the latter part of the book go, I think Book IX is one of the most intriguing because it considers the implications of Avicenna's metaphysics for the connection between God and the world.
Avicenna's account of divine causation refutes the notion that creation must have been initiated in time. If God is eternally present, unchanging, and always possessed of the characteristics through which He brings about existence, then it appears that His effects must result from Him eternally.
I find especially interesting the distinction between eternal dependence and independence. An entity may exist eternally while still being dependent upon its creator. Therefore, the eternity of the universe alone would not show that it exists independently of God.
This perspective has affected my thinking regarding creation in a major way. I think there is much intellectual merit to the view of an eternally dependent universe, mainly because it separates the question of when something began from the question of who its creator is.
One other discussion I find quite compelling is Avicenna's examination, in Book IX, Chapter 6, of divine providence and evil.
Avicenna views evil as deprivation and finds this an attractive alternative to viewing evil as independently existing. Blindness is evil since it signifies the loss of a perfection inherent in beings naturally capable of seeing. Similarly, although fire has positive qualities that can be used for good purposes, it can also produce harmful effects that result in evil.
I find Avicenna's response to reconciling divine providence with evil based on metaphysical reasoning rather than solely relying on humanity's limitations to be helpful. Nevertheless, I do not feel this resolution fully addresses gratuitous suffering. The fact that universal order contains more good than evil does not address why various people suffer severely.
What I Find Most Appealing About This Work
In my estimation, what sets The Metaphysics of the Healing apart from virtually all other philosophical works is the logical connections among Avicenna's arguments.
For instance, Avicenna's account of divine simplicity relies upon his definition of necessary existence. His account of creating an effect through divine causation depends upon his principles regarding causality and immutability. Ultimately, his account of providence relies upon his larger definitions of divine knowledge and natural order.
Therefore, these arguments are not mutually exclusive or independent attempts to prove unrelated conclusions. Instead, they comprise a coherent metaphysical system in which acceptance of one premise may lead to significant implications for others.
Because this is true, The Metaphysics of the Healing is uniquely intellectually stimulating. It prompts readers to consider both whether individual arguments are valid and whether they can provide consistent explanations for reality overall.
I am specifically attracted to Avicenna's emphasis on providing rational explanations for issues that are commonly viewed as beyond philosophy. His arguments encourage consideration of questions such as: Why does anything exist? What does it mean for something to exist necessarily? Does divine freedom require the ability to act otherwise?